No. 274: Merch has become fashion

फेसबुक-विज्ञापन कॉपी 4
Cofounders of Everybody.World

The word merch is synonymous with throwaway. Or at least it used to be. In 2PM’s leading story, Quartzy discusses the changing demographics that have influenced the types of products that luxury brands sell. Gone are the days when famed fashion houses like Gucci focus solely on traditional luxury fashion. Today, their products reflect an affinity for sweat pants, tennis shoes, and modern t-shirt patterns.

This has trickled on down to the merchandise industry. Younger millennials and Gen Z’ers wear merch as a fashion statement and luxury has adopted this burgeoning trend. For merch providers, this means that the American Apparel / LA Apparel aesthetic has given way to something new patterns, styles, and definitions of inclusivity.

2PM recently took a deep dive into the types of merchandising campaigns that are moving the concept of merch away from throwaway and towards luxury. In this archived brief, we explored everything from platforms used to preferred t-shirt patterns and blanks.

Member Brief No. 11: Mega Merch 101

Social media and the normalization of digitally vertical native brands have enabled artists and influencers to create online retail brands as a primary source of revenue. In this report, we will break down best practices – including some insights from our editor’s work with a certain Youtube creator.

Bain Capital released a 2017 report on global luxury that emphasized this shift driven by millennial consumers. Here is an important excerpt:


The Millennial State of Mind: Success in the next decade requires brands to refocus on their customers to better anticipate and cater to their needs. The younger generation will be key as millennials and Gen Z will represent 45 percent of the global personal luxury goods market by 2025. Still, when analysing behaviours, it is more correct to talk about a “millennial state of mind,” which is increasingly permeating across all generations and is thus more a psychographic phenomenon rather than a purely demographic one.

Read the rest here.


To summarize Bain Capital, the Gen Z interpretation of luxury fashion has permeated throughout the entire industry. This has affected consumer industry across footwear, accessories, and apparel. There are merch providers that are well-positioned here.

Business of Fashion’s wrote a recent feature on the two founders of Everybody.World. The write up did a masterful job of explaining how one merch provider built a direct-to-consumer brand that fueled their high growth wholesale business. By working with a curated selection that represents the zeitgeist. This includes: style contributors, graphic designers, a well-designed basics line, and the one staple that has become the go-to for festival merchandisers.

Quality, too, has become increasingly important as concert merch has evolved from souvenir to fashion statement, underscored by merch-like pieces released by luxury brands including Gucci, Balenciaga and Vetements. “The demand is absolutely higher than when I started doing this six years ago,” said Allen, who sourced roughly 70,000 pieces of merch for 2018’s Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival. “And the expectations for the product itself are definitely higher.”

That’s why, this year, Allen looked beyond the typical “blank” T-shirt companies — think Gildan, Bella Canvas and Hanes — to boost Coachella’s offering.

Read more here (unlocked)

Cofounders Iris Alonzo and Carolina Crespo have done an extraordinary job of positioning the Everybody.World brand by building a strong direct-to-consumer business. Something that LA Apparel head Dov Charney is having problems with, this second time around. Due to the successes that they’ve had with wholesaling their famed ‘trash tee’ for $2.90/unit, wholesale traction has allowed the two founders to grow a substantial, higher-margin, direct-to-consumer business. Their main vehicle has been zeitgeist-driven basis and unexpected collaborations with contributors (even Virgil Abloh is listed on the site).

In Q2, merchandise drops have grown to become a major part of the creator narrative. Beyonce’s Coachella performance and her subsequent eCommerce drop was studied in Member Brief No. 11. And above, you’ll see high profile merchandise drops to include: Kanye West, Kid Cudi, and Nas.

As creators continue to emphasize merchandising as an extension of their art (and business), it’s imperative for providers to observe the shifts in the meaning of luxury and how Gen Z consumers have begun to shape the merchandise-turn-fashion industry. For the time being, tees are no longer a dress-down device. And it’s not just about what’s on the shirt, these days. Patterns and fit matter more than ever.

Blanks are no longer viewed as commodity products to a growing segment of American buyers. In fact, the industry is supplying a key component of Gen Z’s fashion identity. There are several providers that are well positioned to grow with the youngest of American consumers.

इस मुद्दे पर अधिक जानकारी यहां पढ़ें।

वेब स्मिथ द्वारा | लगभग 2 बजे

Editor’s note: the next 2PM database (releasing 6/21) will include the most notable of merchandising providers to include Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania’s “Blank” run by Michelle Sharp. This will be a growing database. Join the executive membership for access. 

No. 273: Modern Luxe Doesn’t Bend

वॉटरमार्क_बायटेलरब्रांड्स
Pictured: Outdoor Voices, from our Open Letter to DNVB CEOs

In November of 2016, Lean Luxe’s Paul Munford penned somewhat of a scripture to upstart modern luxury brands: promotion-heavy retailers will not last. There are few takeaways from “The Downward Spiral” that are worth mentioning as recent economic reports suggest that the retail apocalypse is coming to an end, a great sign for aspirational DNVBs that are looking to expand into physical retail.

Screen Shot 2018-06-12 at 10.05.48 AM.png

We are in a time of unprecedented retail brand launches, collaborations, acquisitions, and re-imaginations – much of which is online-first. This begs the question, what will separate the winners from the commodities? There are early and permanent decisions that determine a brand’s trajectory. For every Mizzen + Main or Ministry of Supply, there is a State and Liberty. For every Outdoor Voices, there is a Bandier. And for every Away, there is a Raden. Each decision matters. And no decision matters more than pricing and a brand’s promotional tendencies.

Here are the top ten takeaways from some of Munford’s best work:

  • No maneuver in retail appears to be as easy to roll out, yet no strategy is as detrimental to a retailer’s long term prospects as the heavy discount. It is a palliative pill: wonderful for the consumer in the short run, but ultimately bad for both business and shoppers over time. It commoditizes the brand, forcing companies to differentiate on price. 
  • The second problem, also related to scale, is systemic to the industry itself: The need to constantly add more and more products at regular intervals, flooding the marketplace with goods that are newer, but rarely better.
  • The lure of the discount, then, becomes too hard to resist. It provides a short term boost to the bottom line and the illusion of growth, but at the expense of brand reputation and sustainable profit — two vital arteries for a business’s overall health.
  • Modern luxury companies have figured out the formula, and it’s remarkably simple: create less merchandise than will sell (and predict, if possible, the sell-through rate, with pre-orders), keep demand high. Embrace the waiting list, as Everlane, Glossier, Caraa, and Alala, among others, often do. 
  • Never discount; preserve the standing of the brand. These tactics certainly do not work, however, or at least for very long, if product standards are below par.
  • Hermes, for instance, is notorious for never slashing prices. Its products carry a prestige because of that, and there is always a demand, no matter how frivolous the item. And they certainly are not above testing the limits of consumer devotion: It has even gone so far as to repackage its cutting floor leather scraps to sell them as high-priced gift boxes.
  • That opposition to discounting would come from founders within the emerging modern luxury industry is no coincidence. For one, it displays the trademark sense of calm confidence in the product that this group is quickly becoming known for. 
  • As for Mr. Preysman, the full price mantra feeds into his mission to constantly refine the product, to make it better, and push it ever closer to perfection according to the standards of the brand.
  • Surprisingly, rejecting the discount is also quite consumer-centric. The eternally-wise Ben Franklin said it best, of course, when he offered this observation: “The bitterness of poor quality remains long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten.”
  • It takes superb maturity and a great deal of resilience to fight the urge for the temporary discount boost at the expense of preserving a long term reputation. 

Maturity, patience, grit, and perhaps temporary poverty are keys to developing the types of brands that grow to compete with age old legends and fierce (but hopefully friendly) rivals. In 2013, Brooks Brothers commented on Mizzen + Main’s influence on the shirting industry for the New York Times:

While Brooks Brothers experimented with “performance” shirts akin to Mizzen & Main’s, [Brooks Brothers’ spokesman] Mr. Blee said that customers preferred the general wearability of conventional all-cotton. The stretch fibers felt synthetic to them. Although a range of Brooks Brothers oxford shirts have moisture-wicking properties, he said, “We are known as a natural-fiber house: 100 percent cotton, 100 percent cashmere.

Just five years later, Brooks Brothers is launching a competitor to compete in a menswear world that is being re-defined by technical fabrics and other innovations.

Mizzen+Main on Twitter

we’re old enough to remember when Brooks Brothers laughed at performance menswear: https://t.co/5hBzcUHAEx https://t.co/xCN29dVk81

I remember the joy of that article hitting the newsstands on December 18, 2013. Not because of the notoriety that it would provide but because it had been over a year and half and we really needed the sales. We stood firm on our price while we built allegiances and Kevin worked feverishly to improve the product. And the company lasted. What Lavelle and team has done today is nothing short of spectacular. And it has allowed the brand to stand, eye to eye, in the same clubs and on the same courses as the company that invented the polo shirt (sorry, Ralph).

To achieve growth and longevity, branding cannot be viewed as a soft skill. Price cannot be viewed as an arbitrary number to manipulate. The five forces must always be considered. And patience must be paramount because great brands start slowly. In the age of modern luxury DNVB’s this is as important as the products themselves.

Read more: An Open Letter to DNVB CEOs (Issue No. 254)

Read the rest of Issue No. 273 here.

वेब स्मिथ और मेघन टेरविलिगर द्वारा | लगभग 2 बजे

No. 272: A “Tier A” Path Forward

tierapathforward.jpg

The worst thing to happen to the American mall is the boom of online-first modern luxury companies. And it’s also the best thing to happen to the American mall.

There are 1,100+ malls in America and approximately 320 are graded Tier A. We have an oversupply of malls but that does not mean that traditional, anchored shopping centers no longer have a place in consumerism. We’d argue that Tier A malls have yet to see their best years. We expect their footfall traffic KPIs to grow, while B and C tiered malls continue their trends toward repurposed real estate and other methods to maintain footfall traffic KPIs (mall opportunity, sales opportunity, and store performance).

Suzanne Mulvee, director of research at CoStar, cites that “lower-quality malls in markets with smaller populations and lower incomes will continue to close” —a trend that persists today. And here’s a data based position:

Green Street Advisors, a research firm, forecast a 6.0 percent drop in market revenue per available foot (RevPaF) for class-B and -C malls from 2018 to 2022, versus a 0.5 percent increase for class-A malls during the same period. 

Private market values of class-B and -C malls have also dropped the most since January 2017, according to Green Street, plunging 27.0 percent and 25.0 percent, respectively, year-over-year. Meanwhile, the values of class-A malls declined by 14.0 percent year-over-year.

National Real Estate Investor

So what does this mean for digitally vertical native brands (DNVB), old and new? In short, online-first brands should be positioning their product offering for inclusion in Tier A malls. First, let’s look at the established. A retail presence for DNVBs varies, as such:

  • Harry’s has a prominent position in J. Crew shops (Tier A)
  • Shinola has marquee positioning as stand alone stores (Tier A)
  • Mizzen + Main has prominent position at Nordstrom (Tier A)
  • Bevel has showroom real estate at Macys (Tier A / B)
  • Warby Parker has great stand alone stores (Tier A)
  • Greats has marquee positioning at Nordstrom (Tier A)
  • Ministry of Supply has great stand alone stores in Tier A areas
  • Homage has great stand alone stores (Tier A)
  • Bonobos has stand alone stores and Nordstrom positioning (Tier A)
  • MeUndies has positioning at Nordstrom (Tier A)
  • Goop is opening sponsored pop ups (Tier A)

There are very few presences in Tier B malls and virtually no DNVB presence in Tier C malls. These brands have done a wonderful job positioning themselves as modern luxury companies. They’ve been incubated online for five to ten years and they’ve become prominent enough to live as lifestyle brands in traditional retail spaces. It’s a forgone conclusion that omni-channel operations should be a focus for DNVBs; retail real estate analysis is a skill that is becoming more and more important. And DNVB’s are well-positioned to benefit from the Tier A adoption of the online brands. Recall this quote from Issue No. 265:


2PM’s Meghan Terwilliger had this to say:

Luxury, however you define it, is a brand’s embodiment of characteristics that make it desirable. Historically, those characteristics have been more ‘What’ features like quality, exclusivity, and cost. You can still define luxury as characteristics that make a brand desirable, but those characteristics have shifted. Quality is table stakes.

ब्रांड को और अधिक वांछनीय बनाने वाली विशेषताएँ हैं 'कैसे' विशेषताएँ, जैसे उत्कृष्ट ग्राहक अनुभव (मैं ब्रांड का अनुभव कैसे करूँ), सार्थक ब्रांड मिशन (वे कैसे कुछ वापस देते हैं/बदलाव लाते हैं), और सामुदायिक जुड़ाव। क्या यह कलाकार द्वारा निर्मित और अत्यधिक महंगा है? शायद नहीं। लेकिन अगर यह एक ऐसा उत्पाद है, या यहाँ तक कि एक संपूर्ण अनुभव भी है जो अत्यधिक वांछनीय है, तो इसे एक शानदार ब्रांड माना जा सकता है। DNVBs के पास आधुनिक विलासिता को परिभाषित करने वाली विशेषताओं का समर्थन करने के लिए एक बेहतरीन बुनियादी ढाँचा है।


There are DNVBs that are launching daily. It is important that these brands understand that online retail mechanics has its limits. For these brands to expand into $30 million or more in annual revenue, omni-channel strategy can provide longterm growth. Additionally, this can reinvigorate top funnel sales through online channels.

Here are the top five suggestions for DNVBs launching today:

  • Master the first product. Bonobos began with pants, Mizzen + Main with a single white dress shirt, and Bevel with one blade.
  • Develop a strong sense of product ambassadorship. Mizzen + Main targets millennials, but the most capable buyers are between the age of 34-45. Developing a sense of loyalty with them can pay dividends. For their peers that don’t shop online, they’ll become a top funnel driver of them to your brick and mortar locations.
  • Avoid discount promotion, even at the beginning. Price stability over time is crucial. The moment that a brand is seen as a discounter, the Tier A mall demographic loses interest (with few exceptions).
  • Emphasize advertising to Tier A mall consumers. When DNVB’s grow online, they need to focus on the customers that possess the greatest LTV (lifetime value) potential. This correlates with Tier A mall shoppers.
  • Establish relationships with non-competitive retailers. It can be a powerful signal of longterm viability when existing brands co-sign your early product. This is most often seen by way of product collaborations, cross-promotion, or merchandising your products in their flagship stores.

Retailers that appeal to…the upper class are thriving. One look at Houston’s Galleria, Columbus’ Easton Town Center, or Miami’s Bal Harbour Shops will confirm as such. This is the future that many in retail are planning for. So no, retail is not dead. But retail is leaving the middle class behind because, frankly, so are we.

2PM Member Brief No. 5

In the first sentence, I wrote that online retail is the best and worst thing to happen to malls. In many ways, this is true. The shuttering of weaker retailers and shopping centers is long overdue. Experts attribute this trend to the emergence of online retail brands (and the excessive private equity debt that these retailers accrued to compete with them).

We have more retail real estate than any developed country on earth. Malls are not dying, the bad ones are. While eCommerce efficiency is appealing to digital marketers, the brick and mortar channel is golden for brand operatives who are establishing their brands as modern luxury products. Marketing is arithmetic, whereas brand-building is more of a subjective art. If you were to ask the chief executives at each of the aforementioned brands, they would point to their brick and mortar successes as great milestones. There will be fewer malls in the coming the years, but an early bet on the ones that remain will position young DNVBs for omni-channel success.

Read the rest of the issue.

By Web Smith and Meghan Terwilliger | About 2PM